Critical Review of Knowledge Management Models: Difference between revisions

From MediaWiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
m (Paulreed moved page Critical Review of KM Models to Critical Review of Knowledge Management Models without leaving a redirect)
 
(11 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
==The learning Organization V 6 No 3 1999==
Author MaAdam, McCreedy
Author MaAdam, McCreedy
The learning Oranization V 6 No 3 1999
* There is a lack of classification of suitable Knowledge Management models
* There is a lack of classification of suitable LM management models
* 3 Knowledge Management model classes are critiqued - '''Knowledge Category, Intellectual Capital''' and '''[[term::Socially Constructed]]'''
* 3 KM model calsses are critiqued Knowledge Category, Intellectual Capital and Socially Constructed
* What is the underlying [[Epistemology]] of Knowledge Management? Is knowledge based on scientific data or socially constructed or both (Richardson)?
* What is the underlying [[Epistemology]] of KM - is knowledge based on scientific data or socially constructed or both (Richardson)
* Aim of paper
* Aim of paper
** Clarify definitions
** Clarify definitions
Line 9: Line 10:
** Suggest framework.
** Suggest framework.


De Jarnett KM is k creation, k interpretation, k dissemination, k retention and refinement
De Jarnett - Knowledge Management is knowledge creation, knowledge interpretation, knowledge dissemination, kknowledge retention and refinement
Qunitas Km processing of managing k to meet existing nneds, expliot acquired k and develop new opportunities
Qunitas -  Knowledge management processing is managing knowledge to meet existing needs, exploit acquired knowledge and develop new opportunities.
[[Peters]] " the crux of the issue is not info or IT  it lies more with psychology and maketing of knowledge within the family than with bits and bites
[[Peters]] ''the crux of the issue is not info or IT, it lies more with psychology and makerting of knowledge within the family than with bits and bites'' Knowledge Management is seen as relating to theory and practice - from cognitive psychology. Definitions are not predicated on IT - Peters says it definitely is not - it is an enabler rather than a tenet.


KM is seem as relating to theory and practice - from cognitive psychology
Is [[term::Intellectual Capital]]  the same as Knowledge Management? [[author::Drucker]] ''We are entering the knowledge society in which the basic economic resource is not longer capita it is and will be knowledge'' but Intellectual Capital  is a wider concept that includes patents, copyrights, brands, R&D whereas KM is the strategy and tactics to manage Intellectual Capital. i.e. Leveraging


Definitions are not predicated on IT - Peters says it definitely isnt - its an enabler rather than a tenet
This concept os criticized as too mechanistic by those who see knowledge as '''socially constructed''' Gergen 1991 Alvesson and Willmott 1996


Is IC the same as KM. [[Drucker]] we are entering the knowledge socirty in which the basic economic resource is not longer capita it is and will be knowledge" but IC is a wider concept that includes patents, copyrights, brands, R&D whereas KM is the strategy and tactics to manage IC i.e. Leveraging
==Knowledge Management as a Paradigm==
McLaughlin Thorpe 1993 has it reached the point where is it a toolbox of techniques or a philosophy?


This concept os criticized as too mechanistic by those who see k as socially constructed Gergen 1991 Alvesson and Willmott 1996
'Knowledge is truth' Morgan 1986 Absolutist approach to Knowledge construction associating it with factual inputs
'knowledge as socially constructed' emphasizes cultural and historical proceses rather than rationally superior knowledge -  Burgoyne 1994


!!KM as a paradigm
==Models==
McLaughlin Thorpe 1993 has it reached the point where is it a toolbox of techniques or a philosophy
All models should be treated with caution. They can only be understood with when underyling assumptions and context is known rather than accepting thme as objective representations of reality.


'K is truth' Morgan 1986 absolutist approach to K construction associalting it with factual inputs
===Knowledge Category Models===
'k as socially constructed' emphasizes cultural and historical proceses rather than rationally superior k Burgoyne 1994
====Nonaka====


!!Models
{| class="wikitable" style="text-align: center; color: green;"
All models should be treated with caution. They can only be understood with when underyling assumptions and context is known rather than accepting thme as objective representations of reality
|
|Tacit
|to
|Explicit
|-
|Tacit
|Socialization
|
|Externalization
|-
|from
|-
|Explicit
|Internalization
|
|Combination
|}


!!!Knowledge Category Models
!!!!Nonaka


...............Tacit......to......Explicit
Tacit.......socialization........externalization
from
Explicit...internalization........combination


Model is limited - assumes tacit k can be transferred thru socialization (comradeship)in to tacit and then tacit can become explicit thru externalization (body of K). Explicit can be made tacit thru turning theory in to practice and Explicit to Explicit thru combining existing theories.
*Model is limited - assumes tacit knowledge can be transferred through socialization (comradeship) in to tacit and then tacit can become explicit through externalization (body of Knowledge). Explicit can be made tacit thru turning theory in to practice and Explicit to Explicit through combining existing theories.
*Too mechanistic ignores complexities


Too mechanistic ignores complexities
====Nonaka Hedlund 1993====
Assumes 4 different levels of agents of Knowledge


!!!!Nonaka Hedlund 1993
{| class="wikitable" style="text-align: center; color: green;"
Assumes 4 different levels of agents of K
|
|Individual
|Group
|Organization
|Interorganization
|-
|Articulated
|Knowing
|Quality Controls
|Oragnizational Chart
|Patents
|-
|Knowledge
|Calculus
|
|
|Docs/Process
|-
|Tacit
|Cross-Cultural
|Team
|Culture
|Customers
|-
|Knowledge
|Negotiating Skills
|Coordination
|
|Expectations
|}


............Individual..Group...Organization....Interorg
Criticisms
*Still too segregationalist


Articulated..Knowing....QC's....Org Chart........Patents
===[[author::Boisot]] 1987===
K............Calculus............................Docs/Proc
Considers Knowledge as codified (readily prepared) or uncodified, diffused (readily shared)or undiffused.


Tacit........X-cultural..Team.....Culture........Customers
{| class="wikitable" style="text-align: center; color: green;"
K............Negot skills..coord.................expectns
|
|Undiffused
|Diffused
|-
|Codified
|Proprietary Knowledge
|Public Knowledge
|-
|Uncodified
|Personal Knowledge
|Common Sense
|}


Still too segregationalist
Limited by the discrete categorization of knowledge


!!![[Boisot]] 1987
==Intellectual Capital Models==
Considers K as codified (readily prepared) or uncodified, diffused (readily shared)or undiffused
Chase 1997 sees knowledge management as being segregated in to human, customer, process and growth elements which are contained in two main categoroes of '''human capital''' and '''organizational capital'''.
*Assumes a very scientific approach that knowledge can be commodified
*Ignores political and social aspects of Knowledge Management and that it can be decomposed rather than being a phenomenon.


....................undiffused................diffused
==Socially Constructed==
Assumes wide definitions of knowledge and linked within the social and learning processes within organization


Codified...........proprietary k.............public k
Demerest's adaptation of Staunton and Clark
*Emphasizes construction of Knowledge that is embodied in the org through explicit and social interchange - becomes espoused


Uncodified.........personal k...............common sense
[[File:socially_constructed.jpg|Socially Constructed. Demerest's Adaptation of Staunton and Clark, 1997]]


Limited by the discrete categorization of k
'''Main flow'''
Knowledge Construction to Knowledge Embodiment to Knowledge Dissemination to Knowledge Use.


!!IC Models
'''Recursive'''
Chase 1997 sees km as being segregated in to human, customer, process and growth elements which are contained in 2 main categoroes of human capital ans org capital.
*Use to Knowledge embodiment, construction, dissemination
*Assumes a very scientific approach that kn can be commodified
*Embodiment to constructon  
* ignores political and social aspects of KM and that it can be decomposed rather than being a phenomenon
*Dissemination to embodiment
 
!!Socially Constructed
Assumes wide definitions of K and linked within the social and learning processes within org
 
Demerests adaptation of Staunton and Clark
Emphasizes construction of K that is embodied in the org thru explicit and social interchange - becomes espoused
 
*Main flow
K Construction to K Embodiment to K Dissemination to K
Use.
*Recursive
Use to K embodiment, construction, dissemination
embodiment to constructon dissemination to embodiment


** Invites a more holistic approach
** Invites a more holistic approach
** Limitation is that the recursive arrows have less prominence
** Limitation is that the recursive arrows have less prominence
** the use box is focussed on o/p's and emancipation use
** the use box is focussed on outputs and emancipation use
** Doesnt expand on the processual v circulatory or rapidity.
** Does not expand on the processual v circulatory or rapidity.
Demerest's adaptation adds more arrows to reduce the sequential bias of the other module and addresses bus benefits, emancipation, scientific and social paradigms
*Demerest's adaptation adds more arrows to reduce the sequential bias of the other module and addresses business benefits, emancipation, scientific and social paradigms.
 
==To be added==
Also the research in the article http://www.sosyalarastirmalar.com/cilt2/sayi9pdf/haslinda_sarinah.pdf should be added


[[Category:Knowledge]]
[[Category:Knowledge]]
[[Category:Pages Needing Improvement]]

Latest revision as of 11:13, 27 September 2012

The learning Organization V 6 No 3 1999

Author MaAdam, McCreedy

  • There is a lack of classification of suitable Knowledge Management models
  • 3 Knowledge Management model classes are critiqued - Knowledge Category, Intellectual Capital and Socially Constructed
  • What is the underlying Epistemology of Knowledge Management? Is knowledge based on scientific data or socially constructed or both (Richardson)?
  • Aim of paper
    • Clarify definitions
    • Evaluate models
    • Suggest framework.

De Jarnett - Knowledge Management is knowledge creation, knowledge interpretation, knowledge dissemination, kknowledge retention and refinement Qunitas - Knowledge management processing is managing knowledge to meet existing needs, exploit acquired knowledge and develop new opportunities. Peters the crux of the issue is not info or IT, it lies more with psychology and makerting of knowledge within the family than with bits and bites Knowledge Management is seen as relating to theory and practice - from cognitive psychology. Definitions are not predicated on IT - Peters says it definitely is not - it is an enabler rather than a tenet.

Is Intellectual Capital the same as Knowledge Management? Drucker We are entering the knowledge society in which the basic economic resource is not longer capita it is and will be knowledge but Intellectual Capital is a wider concept that includes patents, copyrights, brands, R&D whereas KM is the strategy and tactics to manage Intellectual Capital. i.e. Leveraging

This concept os criticized as too mechanistic by those who see knowledge as socially constructed Gergen 1991 Alvesson and Willmott 1996

Knowledge Management as a Paradigm

McLaughlin Thorpe 1993 has it reached the point where is it a toolbox of techniques or a philosophy?

'Knowledge is truth' Morgan 1986 Absolutist approach to Knowledge construction associating it with factual inputs 'knowledge as socially constructed' emphasizes cultural and historical proceses rather than rationally superior knowledge - Burgoyne 1994

Models

All models should be treated with caution. They can only be understood with when underyling assumptions and context is known rather than accepting thme as objective representations of reality.

Knowledge Category Models

Nonaka

Tacit to Explicit
Tacit Socialization Externalization
from
Explicit Internalization Combination


  • Model is limited - assumes tacit knowledge can be transferred through socialization (comradeship) in to tacit and then tacit can become explicit through externalization (body of Knowledge). Explicit can be made tacit thru turning theory in to practice and Explicit to Explicit through combining existing theories.
  • Too mechanistic ignores complexities

Nonaka Hedlund 1993

Assumes 4 different levels of agents of Knowledge

Individual Group Organization Interorganization
Articulated Knowing Quality Controls Oragnizational Chart Patents
Knowledge Calculus Docs/Process
Tacit Cross-Cultural Team Culture Customers
Knowledge Negotiating Skills Coordination Expectations

Criticisms

  • Still too segregationalist

Boisot 1987

Considers Knowledge as codified (readily prepared) or uncodified, diffused (readily shared)or undiffused.

Undiffused Diffused
Codified Proprietary Knowledge Public Knowledge
Uncodified Personal Knowledge Common Sense

Limited by the discrete categorization of knowledge

Intellectual Capital Models

Chase 1997 sees knowledge management as being segregated in to human, customer, process and growth elements which are contained in two main categoroes of human capital and organizational capital.

  • Assumes a very scientific approach that knowledge can be commodified
  • Ignores political and social aspects of Knowledge Management and that it can be decomposed rather than being a phenomenon.

Socially Constructed

Assumes wide definitions of knowledge and linked within the social and learning processes within organization

Demerest's adaptation of Staunton and Clark

  • Emphasizes construction of Knowledge that is embodied in the org through explicit and social interchange - becomes espoused

Socially Constructed. Demerest's Adaptation of Staunton and Clark, 1997

Main flow Knowledge Construction to Knowledge Embodiment to Knowledge Dissemination to Knowledge Use.

Recursive

  • Use to Knowledge embodiment, construction, dissemination
  • Embodiment to constructon
  • Dissemination to embodiment
    • Invites a more holistic approach
    • Limitation is that the recursive arrows have less prominence
    • the use box is focussed on outputs and emancipation use
    • Does not expand on the processual v circulatory or rapidity.
  • Demerest's adaptation adds more arrows to reduce the sequential bias of the other module and addresses business benefits, emancipation, scientific and social paradigms.

To be added

Also the research in the article http://www.sosyalarastirmalar.com/cilt2/sayi9pdf/haslinda_sarinah.pdf should be added