Aristotle: Difference between revisions

From MediaWiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 55: Line 55:
Although Aristotle classifies democracy as a deviant constitution (albeit the best of a bad lot), he argues that a case might be made for popular rule. The central claim is that the many may turn out to be better than the virtuous few when they come together, even though the many may be inferior when considered individually. For if each individual has a portion of virtue and practical wisdom, they may pool these assets and turn out to be better rulers than even a very wise individual.
Although Aristotle classifies democracy as a deviant constitution (albeit the best of a bad lot), he argues that a case might be made for popular rule. The central claim is that the many may turn out to be better than the virtuous few when they come together, even though the many may be inferior when considered individually. For if each individual has a portion of virtue and practical wisdom, they may pool these assets and turn out to be better rulers than even a very wise individual.


==The Citizen and the City State==
Wealth should be a means to the end i.e. virtue. It cannot be the thing itself. The citizen needs free time, a slave or servant to carry outtasks so he can pursue virtue and acquire the education. (It implies wealth)




He starts a lyceum. He and his researchers study 158 city states including Sparta, which was a kind of ideal city and Carthage. Sparta - women had too much license. he sees the pairing of wife and husband is a political role. Woman should learn about citizenship as they will be creating citizens. They are different from children or slaves so it was a different kind of rule over women. Their reason is not dominant...too emotional to practice reason.
he finds a definition of citizenship that covers oligarchy and democracy Slaves. he sees natural slaves. No deliberative powers and are naturally born to serve. They cannot find happiness because they cant reason. If he can flourish it is because he has been directed by the master.




He starts a lyceum. He and his researchers study 158 city states including Sparta, which was a kind of ideal city and Carthage. Sparta - women had too much license. he sees the pairing of wife and husband is a political role. Woman should learn about citizenship as they will be creating citizens. They are different from children or slaves so it was a different kind of rule over women. Their reason is not dominant...too emotional to practice reason.
he finds a definition of citizenship that covers oligarchy and democracy Slaves. he sees natural slaves. No deliberative powers and are naturally born to serve. They cannot find happiness because they cant reason. If he can flourish it is because he has been directed by the master.


So must be male, free
The monarchy, aristocracy and polity. They are virtuous because they rule benevolently.


The monarchy, aristocracy and polity. They are virtuous because they rule benevolently. They need free time so they can peruse virtue And acquire the education and it implies wealth


But Wealth should be a means to the end ie virtue. It cannot be the thing itself


Democracy gets a bit of the beating. he sees four types of democracy. the worst ie the best is closest to Oligarchy. The last or ultimate is closest toathens. The mass rules stead of the law. Which is a bit unfair because they were concerned with constitutions. Not adhominem  
Democracy gets a bit of the beating. he sees four types of democracy. the worst ie the best is closest to Oligarchy. The last or ultimate is closest toathens. The mass rules stead of the law. Which is a bit unfair because they were concerned with constitutions. Not adhominem  

Revision as of 13:53, 5 June 2012

Aristotle (384 BC – 322 BC) was a Greek philosopher and polymath, a student of Plato and teacher of Alexander the Great. His writings cover many subjects, including physics, metaphysics, poetry, theater, music, logic, rhetoric, linguistics, politics, government, ethics, biology, and zoology. Together with Plato and Socrates (Plato's teacher), Aristotle is one of the most important founding figures in Western philosophy.


Aristotle was born in Stageiraeast of modern-day Thessaloniki. His father Nicomachus was the personal physician to King Amyntas of Macedon. Aristotle was trained and educated as a member of the aristocracy. At about the age of eighteen, he went to Athens to continue his education at Plato's Academy. He becomes a metic because he was n'\t born in Athens as you cannot change your citizenship. Later, Aristotle was invited by Philip II of Macedon to become the tutor to his son Alexander the Great in 343 BC.

Aristotle Politics

Why do human beings live together?. It is becuase we are political animals. If we want to flourish we have to actualize our capabilities. We are naturally inclined to live in communities, drawing a distiction between nature and culture. Other sophists argued that people are best served if we live according to cultural laws not nature. Aristotle says this is a false dichotomy. We live in a natural state in a polis

In the Nicomachean Ethics Aristotle describes his subject matter as political science, which he characterizes as the most authoritative science. It prescribes which sciences are to be studied in the city-state, and the others -- such as military science, household management, and rhetoric — fall under its authority. Since it governs the other practical sciences, their ends serve as means to its end, which is nothing less than the human good. Populations should live in city states of max. 100 000 people. For Aristotle, it is important who should make decisions.

The formal cause of the city-state is its constitution (politeia). Aristotle defines the constitution as “a certain ordering of the inhabitants of the city-state” He also speaks of the constitution of a community as “the form of the compound” and argues that whether the community is the same over time depends on whether it has the same constitution . The constitution is not a written document, but an organizing principle. Hence, the constitution is also “the way of life” of the citizens. Here, the citizens are the minority of the resident population who possess full political rights. Citizens are distinguished from other inhabitants, such as resident aliens and slaves; and even children and seniors are not unqualified citizens (nor are most ordinary workers). After further analysis he defines the citizen as a person who has the right (exousia) to participate in deliberative or judicial office. He suggests that, although women have a deliberative faculty, it is “without authority”, so that females require male supervision

This sets the stage for the fundamental claim of Aristotle's constitutional theory: “constitutions which aim at the common advantage are correct and just without qualification, whereas those which aim only at the advantage of the rulers are deviant and unjust, because they involve despotic rule which is inappropriate for a community of free persons”



Correct

Deviant


One Ruler

Kingship

Tyranny


Few Rulers

Aristocracy

Oligarchy


Many Rulers

Polity

Democracy


He observes that the dominant class in oligarchy (literally rule of the few) is typically the wealthy, whereas in democracy (literally rule of the dêmos, i.e., people) it is the poor, so that these economic classes should be included in the definition of these forms. Also, polity is later characterized as a kind of “mixed” constitution typified by rule of the “middle” group of citizens, a moderately wealthy class between the rich and poor.

Aristotle and Plato

For Plato, man must access the knowledge of what is good. He must climb out of the cave and view from above and craft the city in the light of the knowledge gained. Aristotle is highly critical of the ideal constitution set forth in Plato's Republic on the grounds that it overvalues political unity. Pragmaticaally, Aristotle says we find what is good by collectively seeking the ideal together. In contrast, in Aristotle's “best constitution,” each and every citizen will possess moral virtue and the equipment to carry it out in practice, and thereby attain a life of excellence and complete happiness. Moreover, there will be a common system of education for all the citizens, because they share the same end.

The Best and Worst Constitutions

Tyranny, democracy oligarchy are all part of the corrupt constitutions because they govern in the interest of the ruler not the ruled. If (as is the case with most existing city-states) the population lacks the capacities and resources for complete happiness, the lawgiver must be content with fashioning a suitable constitution. The second-best system typically takes the form of a polity (in which citizens possess an inferior, more common grade of virtue) or mixed constitution (combining features of democracy, oligarchy, and, where possible, aristocracy, so that no group of citizens is in a position to abuse its rights). Aristotle argues that for city-states that fall short of the ideal, the best constitution is one controlled by a numerous middle class which stands between the rich and the poor.

Although Aristotle classifies democracy as a deviant constitution (albeit the best of a bad lot), he argues that a case might be made for popular rule. The central claim is that the many may turn out to be better than the virtuous few when they come together, even though the many may be inferior when considered individually. For if each individual has a portion of virtue and practical wisdom, they may pool these assets and turn out to be better rulers than even a very wise individual.

The Citizen and the City State

Wealth should be a means to the end i.e. virtue. It cannot be the thing itself. The citizen needs free time, a slave or servant to carry outtasks so he can pursue virtue and acquire the education. (It implies wealth)


He starts a lyceum. He and his researchers study 158 city states including Sparta, which was a kind of ideal city and Carthage. Sparta - women had too much license. he sees the pairing of wife and husband is a political role. Woman should learn about citizenship as they will be creating citizens. They are different from children or slaves so it was a different kind of rule over women. Their reason is not dominant...too emotional to practice reason. he finds a definition of citizenship that covers oligarchy and democracy Slaves. he sees natural slaves. No deliberative powers and are naturally born to serve. They cannot find happiness because they cant reason. If he can flourish it is because he has been directed by the master.


The monarchy, aristocracy and polity. They are virtuous because they rule benevolently.


Democracy gets a bit of the beating. he sees four types of democracy. the worst ie the best is closest to Oligarchy. The last or ultimate is closest toathens. The mass rules stead of the law. Which is a bit unfair because they were concerned with constitutions. Not adhominem

He sees democracy as the one of the corrupt constitutions. Because it is class based governing on behalf of the poor people. Theretically the majority could be rich but it wouldbt be democracy. The essential essence of oligarchy is wealth and the Essential essence of democracy is poverty.

So Virtue is the life to be sought for which can be best reached through an structure because of the wealth, free time, education etc. It is faculty of reason which separates us from natural slaves and animals.

Plato and Aristotle method. . The only common interest is virtue and that would be in the interest of the ruled. Plato says the polis must be unity. Aristotle says it must be diversity in community and accommodate plurality. Unity will destroy polis

the citizenship the ideal pragmatic polity is bit of aristocracy, a bit of democracy and a bit of monarchy a bit like h is Golden Mean

if a extremely virtuous group of one of the groups then they could rule

Bring in the middle class not too rich or poor. State controlled education. Middle class will be less prone to faction. Was he toadying up to Alexander. He was emasculating the city state so was it an implicit criticism

How was his ideas received. His Lyceum thrived. A few centuries later Aristotle writings disappeared until the 8th century in to Arabic and then later by Thomas Acquinas into latin as he linked it to Christianity. Man goverened by natural law the summas

Aristotle gives advice to the tyrant hoping it will push him towards a more virtuous course although Machivelli sees it as a way of maintaining tyranny

Is Aristotle likely to be taken up by authoritarian regimes. . he says that it should be public community virtue. His criticism of extreme democracy is that private virtue allows you to do what you like.