Strategy as Orchestrating Knowledge
Proctor and Gamble are different from Unilever despite marketing same products - Idiosyncratic or tacit knowledge
The Role of disintermediation may lead to the Hollowing out of the Organization by outsourcing to the market but collaboration can create new knowledge.
Codifibale explicit knowledge is being commoditized. Even tacit knowledge is under threat
Deconstruction the value chain - what defensive action can an organization take?
- Open standards allow companies to add value to the grid
- Richness and reach of information (Evans Wurster)
- Focus on a few knowledge-based activities
- Own the supply chain that people / organizations use. For exampe. Internet Explorer: the network that companies sell programs to or Windows
The new Competitve Model
Physical................................Product.............................(fulfillment).........Customer Information..........................Electronic Channels......(info provision)............Customer
The new Value Chain
Outsource.....Core Competence......Collaborate...Customize...Co-specialize....New Capabilities.....Customer
Four information domains
- Strategic - Perceptions about the strategic landscape -Parenting - benchmarking
- Business - Perceptions about competitive environment - Resoures required, positioning
- Organizational informal formal processes, decentralization / centralization
- Knowledge - competence base for each organization
Transaction analysis model - Corporate parents
World View....................Mgt Focus .............HQ-SBU reltionship........... ............Knowledge acquisition and infor req at HQ .............HQ Archetypes.................
Archtypes - Lion Tamer/Mentor/Leader/Trainer
Canon - Mentor, external focus l-t control is embedded in realtionships, x-bpindary learning, double loop, knowdlege diffusion ABB - Leader, external focus, m-l-t, control is discrete, co-ordinated competences, disciplined creativity, self concept enahancement Unilever - Trainer - l-t Centrally managed, single loop, centralized innovation Hanson - Lion Tamer - st cemtal, discrete, efficiency, comformance, compliance, linear communication
Mentor - transformational capacity, empowerment, formal/informal networks Trainer - formal stad protocols Leader Economic performance, external performance, formal lateral and hierarchical linkages Lion tamer - operational efficiency, efficiency dat, internal targets, formal linear hierarchy
Conclusions
- Traditional product based definitions of industries will disappear
- Strategies will become more focused on co-specialized complemenaty best in class
- CA will be based upon knowledge based individual activity
- Horizontal strategy - economies of scope across unrelated industries
- Intermediaries will become flashpoints in the value chain being subject to disintermediation but also potential locus gor highly focused competences
- Formal HQ's to become more informal flexible staged managed to create learning
- Information processes and knowldege networks underpin knowldege learning